SC 36 Plenary 2013

 Information Technology for Learning, Education and Training

 

Secretary’s Report

 

1.Title and scope

Title : JTC 1/SC 36 Information Technology for Learning, Education and Training

Scope : Standardization in the field of information technologies for learning, education and training to support individuals or organization and to enable interoperability and reusability of resources and tools.

 

Excluded :

  • The SC shall not create standards or technical reports that define educational standards, cultural conventions, learning objectives or specific learning content.
  • In the area of work this SC, Standards and technical reports will not duplicate work done by other ISO or IEC TCs/SCs, or WGs with respect to their component, speciality, or domain. Instead, when appropriate, normative or informative references to other stanndards shall be inculded. Examples include documents on speciality topics such as multimedia, web content, cultural adaption and security.

 

  1. Chairman and Secretary

 

JTC 1/SC 36 Chairman:

 

Mr. Erlend Øverby

Karde AS

Åsgårdveien 24, 1671 Kråkerøy,

Norwary

Tel: +47 9012 9642

Fax:

E-mail: erlend.overby@karde.no

 

JTC 1/SC 36 Secretariat:

 

Ms. Eunsook Kim

Korean Agency for Technology and Standards

96 Gyoyukwon-Gil, Gwanchon-si, Gyeonggi-do

427-716, Rep. of Korea

Tel: +82 2 509 7264

Fax: +82 2 509 7068

E-mail: eunsook@kats.go.kr

  1. JTC 1/SC 36 Memebership
P-Member  bodies: 23   O-member bodies: 22
No Country National Body   Country National Body
1 Algeria IANOR Belgium NBN
2 Australia SA Bosnia and Herzegovina BAS
3 Canada SCC Colombia ICONTEC
4 China SAC Czech Republic UNMZ
5 Denmark DS Finland SFS
6 France AFNOR Ghana GSA
7 Germany DIN Hong Kong

(Correspondent member)

ITCHKSAR
8 India BIS Hungary MSZT
9 Italy UNI Indonesia BSN
10 Japan JISC Iran, Islamic Rep. of ISIRI
11 Kenya KEBS Ireland NSAI
12 Rep. of Korea KATS Kazakhstan KAZMEMST
13 Luxembourg ILNAS Malaysia DSM
14 Netherlands NEN New Zealand SNZ
15 Norway SN Romania ASRO
16 Portugal IPQ Saudi Arabia SASO
17 Russian Federation GOST R Serbia ISS
18 Slovakia SUTN Singapore SPRING SG
19 South Africa SABS Sweden SIS
20 Spain AENOR Switzerland SNV
21 Tunisia INNORPI Turkey TSE
22 Ukraine DSSU United States ANSI
23 United Kingdom BSI
Portugal(IPQ) has joined SC 36 as P-Member.
Liaisons
No Internal: 7 External: 7
1 ISO/TC 37 Terminology and other language and content resources ADL: Advanced Distributed Learning
2 ISO/TC 37/SC 2 Terminographical and lexicographical working methods AICC: Aviation Industry CBT Committee
3 ISO/TC 46 Information and documentation AUF: Agence Universitaire de la Francophonie
4 ISO/TC 176 Quality management and quality assurance IMS: IMG Global Learning Consortium
5 ISO/TC 211 Geographic information/Geomatics Infoterm: International Information Centre for Terminology
6 ISO/TC 232 Learning services outside formal education LETSI: International Federation for Learning-Education-Training Systems Interoperability
7 ISO/TC 215 Health informatics LTSC: IEEE Technology Standards Committee

 

 

  1. JTC 1/SC 36 Structure and officers

JTC 1/SC 36 operates with the following working groups and ad hoc groups :

WG/AG Title Convener
AG 1/BPC Advisory Group on Business Planning and Communications SHIN, Sung-Wook(KR)
WG 1 Vocabulary Mokhtar Ben Henda(FR)
WG 2 Collaborative Technology Toshio Okamoto(JP)
WG 3 Learner information Bernard Blandin(FR)
WG 4 Management and delivery of learning, education and training CHO, Yong-Sang(KR)
WG 5 Quality assurance and descriptive framework Christian M. Stracke(GE)
WG 6 Platform, Services and Specification Integration Zhu Wu Di(CH)
WG 7 ITLET-Culture, language and individual needs Erlend Øverby(NO)
Adhoc groups Green ICT SHON, Jin-Gon(KR)
Adhoc groups Digital Content CHO, Yong-Sang(KR)
HDAG Head of Delegation Advisory Group Erlend Øverby(NO)

 

  1. Past JTC 1/SC 36 Meetings
No. Date Location Approximate Total Attendance
27 2014 To be decided
26 2013-09-07/13 Moscow, Russia
25 2012-09-8/15 Busan, Korea 78
24 2011-09 Shanghai, China 67
23 2011-03 Strasbourg, France 62
22 2010-09 State College, US 58
21 2010-03 Osaka, Japan 68
20 2009-09 Umeå, Sweden 64
19 2009-03 Wellington, New Zealand 62
18 2008-09 Stuttgart, Germany 68
17 2008-03 Jeju Island, Korea 73
16 2007-09 Toronto, Canada 70
15 2007-03 London, UK 73
14 2006-09 Wuhan, China 75
13 2006-03 Turku, Finland 81
12 2005-09 Durham, US 79
11 2005-03 Tokyo, Japan 78
10 2004-09 Dublin, Ireland 61
9 2004-03 Montreal, Canada 75
8 2003-09 Seoul, Korea 50
7 2003-03 Paris, France 85
6 2002-09 Lawrence, Kansas, US 50
5 2002-03 Adelaide, Australia 40
4 2001-09 Copenhagen, Denmark Cancelled
3 2001-03 New York City, US 35
2 2000-09 Sedona, US 25
1 2000-03 London, UK 35
  1. Status of JTC 1/SC 36 Program of Work

The following figures are an indication of SC 36’s activity since last JTC 1/SC 36 Plenary(2012)

  • 36 active projects
  • 19 votes started in the past 10 months. 8 votes were approved and 11 votes in under ballot.
  • 2 standards published

6.1 Systematic reviews (2013)

Ongoing reviews Title Closing date
ISO/IEC 19778-1 ITLET — Collaborative technology – Collaborative workplace – Part 1: Collaborative workplace data model 2013-9-16
ISO/IEC 19778-2 ITLET- Collaborative technology – Collaborative workplace – Part 2: Collaborative environment data model 2013-9-16
ISO/IEC 19778-3 ITLET-Collaborative technology – Collaborative workplace – Part 3: Collaborative group data 2013-9-16
ISO/IEC 19780-1 ITLET- Collaborative technology — Collaborative learning communication — Part 1: Text-based communication 2013-9-16

 

Planned reviews Title Closing date
ISO/IEC 12785-1 ITLET – Content packaging –Part 1: Information Model 2014
ISO/IEC 19796-3 ITLET – Quality management, assurance and metrics – Part 3: Reference methods and metrics 2014
ISO/IEC TR 29163-1 IT – Sharable Content Object Reference Model(SCORM®) 2004 3rd Edition – Part 1: Overview version 1.1 2014
ISO/IEC TR 29163-2 IT-Sharable Content Object Reference Model (SCORM®) 2004 3rd Edition — Part 2: Content Aggregation Model Version 1.1 2014
ISO/IEC TR 29163-3 Information technology — Sharable Content Object Reference Model (SCORM®) 2004 3rd Edition — Part 3: Run-Time Environment Version 1.1 2014
ISO/IEC TR 29163-4 Information technology — Sharable Content Object Reference Model (SCORM®) 2004 3rd Edition — Part 4: Sequencing and Navigation Version 1.1 2014

6.2 Published standards (2013)

ISO/IEC 29187-1:2013 IT – Identification of privacy protection requirements pertaining to learning, education and training (LET) — Part 1: Framework and reference model
ISO/IEC 12785-1:2009/Cor 1. 2013

 

 

6.3 Project with Warning status

ISO/IEC PDTS 20006-3

DIS should be registered by 2013-12-12

Cancellation date 2015-6-12

 

6.4 Project with Critical status

ISO/IEC DTS 20013

FDIS should be registered by 2013-08-08

Cancellation date 2014-02-08

 

6.5 Project with withdrawal

ISO/IEC 2382-36 :2008/Damd 1

 

 

6.6 Active work items(31 projects)

Stage Reference Title WG Limit date
50.20 ISO/IEC FDIS 2382-36 :2008(Ed 2) Information technology – Vocabulary – Part 36: Learning, education and training – Amendment 1 1
30.20 ISO/IEC PDTR 18120 e-Textbook 6
30.20 ISO/IEC PDTR 18121 Virtual Experiments 6
10.99 ISO/IEC NP TR 19778-4 ITLET – Collaborative technology – Collaborative workplace – Part 4: User guide for implementing, facilitating and improving collaborative applications 2
40.60 ISO/IEC 19788-1:2011/DAmd 1 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 1: Framework – Amendment 1 4 2014-7-10
30.99 ISO/IEC CD 19788-4 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources– Part 4: Technical elements 4 2013-10-1

(extened)

40.00 ISO/IEC CD 19788-6 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 6: Availability, distribution, and intellectual property elements 4 2014-3-15

(extened)

10.99 ISO/IEC NP 19788-7 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 7: Bindings 4 2013-10-14
30.20 ISO/IEC CD 19788-8 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 8: Data elements for MLR records 4 2014-3-27
30.20 ISO/IEC CD 19788-9 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 9: Data elements for Persons 4 2014-3-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 19788-10 ITLET – Metadata for learning resources – Part 10: Application Profile for Access, Distribution and Intellectual Property (WIPO compliant) elements 4 2014-3-27
30.99 ISO/IEC PDTR 19796-4 ITLET – Quality management, assurance and metrics – Part 4: Best practice and implementation guide 5 (extended)
40.99 ISO/IEC DTR 19796-5 ITLET – Quality management, assurance and metrics — Part 5: How to use ISO/IEC 19796-1 5 2013-12-22

(extended)

10.99 ISO/IEC NP 19796-6 ITLET – Part 6: Conformity Assessment Model 5 2014-9-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 19796-7 Information technology — Quality for learning, education and training — Part 7: Products and services — Requirements 5 2014-3-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP TR 20006 ITLET – Information Model for Competency 3
40.20 ISO/IEC DIS 20006-1 ITLET – Information Model for Competency — Part 1: Competency General Framework and Information Model 3 2014-3-6
30.60 ISO/IEC CD 20006-2 ITLET – Information Model for Competency — Part 2: Proficiency Level Information Model 3 2012-9-6
30.00 ISO/IEC PDTS 2006-3 ITLET – Information Model for Competency — Part 3: Guidelines for the Aggregation of Competency Information and Data 3 2014-12-12

(extended)

40.99 ISO/IEC DTS 20013 ITLET – Conceptual Model for e-Portfolio information 3 2013-8-8
50.20 ISO/IEC FDIS 20016-1 ITLET – Language accessibility and human interface equivalencies (HIEs) in e-learning applications – Part 1: Framework and reference model for semantic interoperability 7
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 20016-2 ITLET – Human interface equivalencies — Part 2: Template for Specifying Levels of Semantic Unambiguity 7 2014-3-27
90.60 ISO/IEC 23988 :2007(Ed 1) Information technology — A code of practice for the use of information technology (IT) in the delivery of assessments
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 24751-2 Information technology – Individualized adaptability and accessibility in e-learning, education and training – Access for all – Part 2: Registry 7 2014-3-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 24751-3 Information technology – Individualized adaptability and accessibility in e-learning, education and training – Access for all – Part 3: Application profile 7 2014-3-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 29187-2 Information technology – Identification of privacy protection requirements pertaining to learning, education and training (LET) – Part 2: Guidelines for information life cycle management and EDI of personal information 3 2014-3-27
10.99 ISO/IEC NP 29187-3 Information technology – Identification of privacy protection requirements pertaining to learning, education and training (LET) – Part 3: Multilingual Vocabulary 3 2014-3-27
30.20 ISO/IEC CD 30119-1 Quality Standard for the Creation and Delivery of Fair, Valid and Reliable e-Tests — Part 1: Quality framework for e-Tests 5 2014-6-1
30.00 ISO/IEC CD 30119-2 Quality Standard for the Creation and Delivery of Fair, Valid and Reliable e-Tests — Part 2: Application guide with use cases 5 2014-10-1
20.00 ISO/IEC AWI 36000 Quality for learning, education and training — Fundamentals and vocabulary 5 2014-3-26
30.20 ISO/IEC CD 36001 Quality for learning, education and training — Management systems — Requirements 5 2014-3-10

*A project is automatically cancelled if:

  • the limit date for DIS is not met and if the TC/SC has not taken and implemented a decision within 6 months after the limit date has expired.
  • the limit date for FDIS is not met and if the TC/SC has not taken and implemented a decision within 6 months after the limit date has expired.

 

  1. Report of Previous meeting Resolution

7.1 Request for freely available stadnards

Resolution Number Regarding Action
12(WG3) ISO/IEC 29187-1 -Submission to JTC 1 as SC36 N2502(2012-9-28)

– Agenda fo JTC 1 : JTC 1 N11209(2012-9-25)

Approved at JTC 1 Plenary : JTC 1 N11429(2012-11-15)

35(WG4) ISO/IEC 12785-1,-2 and ISO/IEC TR 12785-3 – Submission to JTC 1 as SC36 N2502(2012-9-28)

– Submit again to JTC 1 for ballot as SC 36 N2528(2012-11-23)

60(WG7) ISO/IEC 20016-1 -Submission to JTC 1 as SC36 N2502(2012-9-28), N2503(2012-9-28)

– Agenad of JTC 1 Pleanry : JTC 1 N11308(2012-10-4)

– Submit again to JTC 1 for ballot SC 36 N2529(2012-11-23)

7.2 Extension of time frame 

Resolution Number Regarding Action
19(WG 3) ISO/IEC 20006-3(18Month) -Submission to JTC 1 for default letter ballot as JTC 1 N11225

Approved as SC 36 N2531

 

34(WG4) ISO/IEC 19788-4 & 6(12Month)
37(WG 5) ISO/IEC 19796 all parts(12Month)
38(WG5) ISO/IEC 30119 all parts(12Month)

7.3 Project subdivision, Project registration, title change and Type Change 

please refer to the above active work items

7.4 Others

Resolution Number Regarding Action
69 Questions about post-voting decision process – Agenda for JTC 1 as JTC 1N11247

– Response from ITTF as SC 36 N2530(JTC 1N11392)

* The post-voting decision is a tool only used by Secretariat after the ballot close.

71 Request on simplified RER -Send the JTC 1 as SC 36N2488

– Agendar for JTC 1 as JTC 1N11246

– Refer to JTC 1 N11429(see to the Resolution 8)

72 Line reference in ballot document -Send the JTC 1 as SC 36N2489

– Agenda for JTC 1 as JTC 1N11244

73 TMB Resolution 14/2012 improving standards development process – Send to JTC 1 as SC 36 N2405

– Response from JTC 1 as SC 36 N2522(JTC 1 N11430)

* Not to appy the ISO New process in JTC 1.

 

Respectfully submitted,
Eunsook Kim
JTC 1/SC 36 Secretariat